Hope in rising waters: Eco-San toilets provide secure sanitation for flood-affected communities in West Champaran, Bihar, India

   TwitCount
Debabrat Sukla
Anjal Prakash

This year’s devastating rains have brought challenges to flood-ravaged communities in Bangladesh, Nepal and northern India, particularly to sanitation. However, a flood-resilient toilet being tested in North-Western Bihar could make sanitation safe and secure for the flood-affected communities.

Numerous communities have been affected in the wake of significant rainfall that has lashed the India-Nepal-Bangladesh region in mid-August 2017. Photos from these affected areas show people on boats and makeshift rafts, transporting their valuables to safer ground. Some of these photos depict people carrying their possessions on their shoulders in chest-deep water.

On 13-14 August incessant rain along the Nepal-India border caused significant flooding in many districts of Bihar. On 23 August, the flood situation in Bihar worsened as the number of deaths mounted to more than 300. The deluge has affected nearly,”...1.4 crore people in...18 districts”. In Nepal, 50,000 people have been left stranded in the plain regions and a further 91,000 households have been temporarily displaced in 28 districts.

Apart from these challenges, another threat awaits in the stagnant waters: waterborne diseases. In flood conditions, drinking water becomes a luxury to come by as many sources are either fully or partially inundated, rendering them useless. People who try to use hand pumps in flooded areas may consume contaminated water. They can also contract waterborne diseases through contact with stagnant floodwaters. In these times, women face greater threats to exposure as they are forced to carry out their day-to-day activities (e.g., washing, bathing) in contaminated waters.

Figure 1: Based on the Flood Inundation Application, large parts of the western part of Paschim Champaran have faced flooding. In the image, light blue portions of the map show inundated areas. 
Source: Web Application, ICIMOD, 2017

In Naya Tola Bishambharpur (NTB), in the West Champaran district of Bihar, the watery quagmire surrounding the village poses formidable challenges. NTB borders Nepal to the north, and the upstream precipitation in this region greatly influences the amount of water that flows down into the region. This map ( figure 1 ) from the International Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) shows the entire western part of the district has been submerged in rain and flood waters.

Figure 2: A closeup of the Naya Tola Bishambharpur, where the eco-san toilets are being built. Source: 
Source: Web Application, ICIMOD, 2017

Weekly spatial rainfall data analysis from the Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) shows that between 10-16 August West Champaran received anywhere between 240 to 600 mm of rainfall. The amount of rainfall received in such a short period of time has had lasting impacts on communities living in the district. The latest statistics show that there have been 13 deaths in the district alone due to flooding.

Figure 3: Snapshot of spatial rainfall data from IMD, for West Champaran

During floods, sanitation becomes a particular problem as people have reduced means of maintaining personal hygiene, especially with regard to defecation. Open defecation only adds to the contamination of ground water, which then affects those who use it for household uses. A workable solution would require addressing multiple needs regarding clean drinking water and secure sanitation. 

Figure 4: A woman wades through knee deep water in NTB. 
Credit: Aparna Unni

To this end, the phaydemand sauchalaya (PS), or eco-san toilet, was introduced in NTB to address the needs of safe and secure sanitation. Through its innovative structural design, the PS offers an effective means of addressing sanitation compared to standard flush toilets. In the alluvial flood plains of Bihar, the use of flush toilets increases the risk of contaminating the shallow water table. Such toilets also face clogging, raising the risk of infection for users, specifically women and children, in a region frequented with floods.

The PS as explained in a brief by Megh Pyne Abhiyan, is constructed on raised platforms to ensure access even during flood conditions. The height of the toilets is determined based on the highest flood water levels anticipated in the area. The seat of the toilet itself has two different openings that collect urine and fecal matter. These openings are connected to two separate storage tanks below the toilet, which are situated above ground. Because the PS is a dry toilet, the breakdown of fecal matter creates no foul odor. The collection pits can be accessed by openings created by uncemented bricks positioned at the back of the PS structure. Fecal matter now in its form as humanure can be applied to crops as fertilizer, and the urine as a urea substitute. As a flood adaptive technology, the toilet not only provide secure use, but due to its water-less design, also cuts the risk of groundwater contamination and successive infections entirely.

Figure 5: A jar of humanure after being naturally processed in the collection pit of an eco-san toilet. 
Credit: Avash Pandey

Any successful technology intervention must be adopted by the intended beneficiaries. Have PS toilets met this requirement? A study by Purnamita Dasgupta at the Institute of Economic Growth, New Delhi, says, “yes.” Dasgupta’s 2016 study details high levels of vulnerability to floods and extreme health risks faced in Paschim Champaran due to inadequate sanitation. Her team did a cost-benefit analysis of adopting eco-san toilets and found that substantial health costs and convenience losses can be averted by ensuring access to toilets in Paschim Champaran. Ecological sanitation options provide the most cost-effective adaptation option where benefits exceed way beyond the cost. 

Live examples of toilets that are currently being used by households in the Kairi community in Paschim Champaran indicate a promising future for households in NTB. The village of Kairi in Gaunaha block of Paschim Champaran, close to the Nepal border, is in a region prone to flash-floods, and stands testimony to the effectiveness of PS as a viable solution for sanitation in flood-affected regions. Since 2015, residents of the village have been taking up the construction of the toilets one by one, seeing the positive reaction from their neighbours who had already done so. On 8 August, the flood waters rushed through the village entering homes, creating new channels for streams in the fields and even washing away an embankment of geo-bags along the Pandai River, on whose banks the village is located. But the PS remained standing. And accessible. The flood waters that came to Kairi only remained for a few hours, but even at their peak level, the top steps of the toilet remained above the water.

Figure 5 A woman indicates the last flood water levels that inundated the Kairi village. The toilet was still accessible. 
Credit: Aparna Unni

During the flood, the toilet built in Chatti Devi’s house in Paschim Champaran was unaffected by the rising waters, accessible and usable the entire time. This is a promising turn of events, as the level of floodwaters reported in this area have been the highest, even compared to worse flood events in recent memory, such as those in 1993. Waterborne diseases do not directly arise from the use of these toilets, because the chambers protect the waste matter from direct contact with the flood water. This also proves the efficacy of eco-san toilet which is a cost effective technology and can provide crucial access to sanitation during floods. This is a sign – a hope – that despite the rising floodwaters, those using the toilets have a safe and secure place for defecation. It also is a step forward in using greener means of fertilizing Chatti Devi’s fields.

Figure 6: Picture of the eco-san structure, with its toilet accessible above the water at Chatti Devi's house. 
Credit: Kumod Kumar Das (Megh Pyne Abhiyan)

Since Dasgupta’s study all indicates that the region faces major risks, including increased flood events and a potential increase in frequency and associated flow levels, the eco-san toilet can provide safe sanitation and reduce the risk of illness from waterborne diseases.

Note

  • Debabrat Sukla is Knowledge Management Focal Point for the HI-AWARE initiative at ICIMOD. 
  • Anjal Prakash is Programme Coordinator (HI-AWARE), and Coordinating Lead Author for the upcoming AR6 report on oceans and the cryosphere, by the IPCC
  • Aparna Unni is Programme Officer (Water) at Megh Pyne Abhiyan