This site uses cookies, as explained in our terms of use. If you consent, please close this message and continue to use this site.
Independent Evaluation Unit (IEU) ensures the ICIMOD is accountable and effective in delivering according to its mandate. It conducts evaluations independently of ICIMOD activities, policies and procedures to ensure its accountability and capture learnings from high-quality evaluations to help and support ICIMOD’s effectiveness and efficiency.
ICIMOD Board established the IEU post approval of evaluation policy in 2024. This is the first formal ICIMOD Evaluation Policy, incorporating learning from twenty years of previous evaluation experience in ICIMOD. It sets out the scope and coverage of evaluation in ICIMOD; evaluation principles, values and criteria; roles and responsibilities; and processes and partnerships. The IEU is managed by a Chief of Evaluation and Learning and reports to the Director General and presents IEU Plan, budget and recommendations to the Evaluation Sub-Committee of the Board.
The Board has also established an Evaluation Sub-Committee (ESC) as an oversight body to ensure that evaluations are conducted independently. The ESC makes regular recommendations to the Board related to the following:
The IEU has a mandate to conduct independent evaluations to inform policies and decisions both by the management and the Board, and disseminate lesson learned. The IEU follows up on the management responses to the evaluation recommendations and presents the status to the ESC on regular basis.
from evaluations will be considered as part of ICIMOD’s wider commitments to improving knowledge management and learning. Learning will be incorporated in evaluation processes, for example through early discussion with key stakeholders of emerging findings and recommendations. All new projects and plans must demonstrate that they have considered relevant learning from evaluations (as well as other sources including self-assessment reviews). Innovations normally need robust evidence of cost-effectiveness before ICIMOD supports scaling; such evidence may come from various sources, but this will often include an impact assessment.
ICIMOD staff with core evaluation responsibilities will be recruited, trained, and promoted against defined evaluation competencies. Basic evaluative concepts will also form part of training for professional staff, including theory of change, the limitations of monitoring data, interpretation of key data types, ethics, impartiality, and quality aspects. This training will include selected key partners where appropriate (if demand and resources exist).
The IEU ensures that the following principles must be followed while conducting evaluations.
The rationale for an evaluation and the management decisions to be based on its findings should be clear from the outset.
Evaluations must take into account the type of work that ICIMOD does. This includes long-term, complex impact pathways (via changes in policy, capability, and innovation) and working through partners.
Including relevant cross cutting issues (as agreed), such as GESI, climate change, and biodiversity.
Management must not impose restrictions on the scope, content, comments, and recommendations of evaluation reports (within budget frame). Evaluators must be free of conflict of interest.
Evaluators must avoid bias and strive to be objective, while promoting participation and consultation of stakeholders.
Evaluation should not reflect personal or sectoral interests. Evaluators must have professional integrity, respect the rights of institutions and individuals to provide information in confidence, safeguard vulnerable people, and be sensitive to the beliefs and customs of local social and cultural environments.
The selection process and criteria for evaluation topics will be clearly specified in evaluation workplans. Evaluation plans and reports will be made public
All evaluations should meet ICIMOD Evaluation Quality Standards. This includes choosing an appropriate approach and methods to answer the evaluation questions within the resources available, and realism of conclusions. Strengths and limitations of the methods and data, and any assumptions, will be clearly communicated in evaluation reports.
Evaluations must be designed and completed in a timely fashion to inform decisions.
All evaluations should produce clear, actionable recommendations as well as useable lessons, both backward and forward looking.
Key stakeholders should be consulted on draft findings, lessons, and recommendations.